Best all-around pencils
Prismacolor Premier Soft Core, 72-count
Rich, soft pencils that make layering and blending feel forgiving. The one-set answer if you want to color, shade, and not overthink it.
See the pencils on AmazonMaggie's pencil opinions
The good stuff for coloring through your sh*t.
Start with the thing that sounds fun. You do not need a craft-store intervention to enjoy one page.
Amazon link disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Best marker rabbit hole
Ohuhu Honolulu, 48-color brush & chisel set
A good entry point for smooth, bold color: a brush tip for details, a chisel tip for bigger spaces, and refillable alcohol ink.
Heads-up: Alcohol markers can bleed through paper. Put a scrap sheet behind the page and test a tiny corner first.
See the markers on Amazon
Best finishing move
Sakura Gelly Roll Classic White, 3-pack
Use these opaque white pens for tiny highlights, stars, shine, and the satisfying final bit that makes a page look finished.
See the white pens on Amazon